Choosing Between Gas and Electric Water Heaters: What’s Best for You?

August 27, 2025

If you’re a homeowner in Victoria or the surrounding areas, your hot water heater is one of the hardest working appliances in your home. From hot showers to dishwashing and laundry, you rely on a steady supply of hot water every day. When it’s time to replace your water heater or install a new one, a crucial decision awaits: should you choose a gas or electric water heater? And importantly, which brand delivers the quality and reliability you can trust long-term? At Wade Roberts Plumbing, we confidently recommend Rheem water heaters—a top choice for homes throughout Vancouver Island.


Understanding How Gas and Electric (Rheem) Water Heaters Work


Rheem offers both highly efficient gas and electric water heater models. Rheem gas water heaters use natural gas or propane to quickly heat water within a durable, well-insulated tank, while safely venting exhaust outdoors. Rheem electric water heaters utilize powerful electric elements submerged in the tank for consistent, efficient heating.


Among electric options, the Rheem Marathon electric water heater stands out for its incredible durability, energy efficiency, and industry-leading lifetime warranty on the tank—making it a favourite in Victoria homes seeking long-term value and eco-friendly performance.


Key Factors to Consider for Victoria Homeowners


1. Energy Efficiency and Operational Cost


Rheem gas water heaters typically heat up water quickly and operate at low monthly costs if natural gas rates are favourable (as they often are in BC). Meanwhile, the Rheem Marathon electric heater features exceptional insulation, translating to ultra-efficient performance and minimal standby heat loss, which can help offset higher electricity rates.


2. Installation and Space Requirements


Rheem gas heaters require venting and access to a gas line, which may limit placement. In contrast, the Rheem Marathon and Rheem’s other electric water heaters are easier to install in tight or unconventional spaces, needing only an electrical hookup.


3. Performance and Hot Water Recovery Rate


Households with high hot water demand benefit from Rheem’s rapid-recovery gas models, which can keep up with multiple back-to-back showers. The Rheem Marathon electric water heater is designed with higher-capacity models suitable for busy families, offering superior performance even during heavy use.


4. Lifespan and Maintenance


Rheem is known for quality and longevity. The Rheem Marathon’s polybutene tank construction means it’s highly resistant to rust, corrosion, and leaks—practically eliminating routine tank replacement. Both Rheem gas and electric models are engineered for easy maintenance and long service life when properly cared for.


5. Environmental Impact


Victoria and Vancouver Island homeowners value sustainability. Rheem electric water heaters—especially the Marathon series—are compatible with BC Hydro’s clean energy grid, keeping your hot water carbon-friendly. Rheem gas heaters are among the most energy-efficient in their class, using advanced technology to minimize emissions.


Making the Right Choice with a Trusted Professional


At Wade Roberts Plumbing, we’re proud to be a preferred installer of Rheem water heaters. Our knowledge extends across their entire gas and electric lineup, including the best-in-class Rheem Marathon and standard Rheem gas tanks. We’ll help you navigate every consideration—from space and fuel type to budget and performance—to find the perfect Rheem solution for your home.


Ready to Upgrade Your Water Heater with Rheem?


With over 20 years serving Victoria and Vancouver Island, Wade Roberts Plumbing is the name homeowners trust for expert water heater advice, installation, and support. Contact us today for a personalized consultation—let us help you discover the Rheem gas or electric water heater that brings efficient, reliable hot water to your home for years ahead.


Don’t settle for less than the best. Choose Rheem. Choose comfort. Choose Wade Roberts Plumbing.


Plumber shaking hands with a woman in a kitchen; paperwork visible.
November 25, 2025
Be holiday-host ready. Use our pro plumbing checklist to prevent kitchen sink clogs, cold showers, and toilet troubles. 5-star tips from Wade Roberts Plumbing.
White electric water heater mounted on a gray tiled wall.
November 19, 2025
Tankless vs. tank in BC winters: recovery rates, sizing, venting, and costs. See what works for Victoria homes and when Wade Roberts recommends replacement.
Electric water heater mounted on a textured wall; with blue and red water connections.
November 11, 2025
Hosting guests? Find out how many showers your tank supports, quick ways to boost hot water, and when a tankless upgrade makes sense. Serving Greater Victoria.
Water flowing down a shiny, silver sink drain.
November 5, 2025
Heavy rain can overload drains. Learn how to prevent backups, protect your home, and when to call Wade Roberts Plumbing for 24/7 help across Greater Victoria.
Cutaway diagram of Navien tankless water heater components, showing sections and labels. Includes the unit's controls and pump housing.
October 29, 2025
Considering a tankless system? Uncover the benefits and drawbacks of tankless water heaters for Victoria households.
White Navien tankless water heater with digital display and Energy Star label.
October 21, 2025
Unsure if your water tank needs replacing? Learn the clear signs and benefits of timely hot water tank replacement.
A man on the phone and a woman holding a bucket look up at a ceiling leak in a modern home.
October 15, 2025
Be ready for anything. Discover how Wade Roberts Plumbing handles plumbing emergencies, day or night.
A woman in an orange shirt is talking on the phone while looking at something on a shelf. She has dark hair in a ponytail.
October 7, 2025
Avoid major repairs by spotting early signs of plumbing issues in Victoria’s older homes. Get expert insight now.
Show More